About

Set in Old Town Eureka, this local favorite cafe serves up coffee and decadent desserts. They're a hot spot not only due to their their quality beverages and sweets. On numerous occasions, they have been voted the best specialty coffee, coffee house, best product, and best dessert. Treat yourself and give this Redwoods coffee shop a visit!

Specialty Coffee & Beverages

Quality coffee depends on two main aspects - quality beans and quality roasting equipment. Old Town Coffee has both these things which is why people keep coming back for more! As for beans, they only use the best Arabica green beans from the most renowned coffee growing regions in the world. When it comes to roasting equipment, they use Dietrich roasters which are known to reduce smoke. The coffee menu boasts over 4 dozen varietals with organic and regular beans. Some regions they source from include Brazil, Columbia, Kenya, Peru, Italy, and more. They also offer blends based on roast, decaffeinated coffee, and even flavored coffees. This cafe is a coffee lovers dream!

Alternatively, there is still plenty of selection on the menu for non-coffee drinkers. They have plenty of specially brewed teas and blended smoothies and frappes.

Eureka's Best Fudge & Chocolates

Made in-house, their award-winning fudge is a must try! They use fresh butter and cream which is what sets their fudge apart from the rest. In addition, they have plenty of flavors for every taste palette. They keep seven types of fudge on-hand at all times, while they also add seasonal flavors throughout the year. Their always-available flavors include classics such as Chocolate, Maple Pecan, Rocky Road, and more. Rotating seasonal flavors include Butter Pecan, Key Lime, Snickers Bar, Strawberry, Amaretto Swirl and more. Be sure to ask what seasonal fudge is available when you visit!

Aside from fudge, they carry all kinds of tasty confections including fudge and caramel-dipped apples, chocolate bars, single chocolates, cookies, scones, and more. Drool over all their options in the windows at the cashier stand.

Breakfast Food

As a popular morning hangout and coffee shop, Old Town offers a few different breakfast and lunch options to go with your morning pick-me-up. Whether you're finishing a run at the beach, or need fuel for axe throwing, Old Town has something for everyone. They have an assortment of bagels, breakfast burritos, wraps, and other handhelds (Available at their Henderson Location).

Old Town Coffee Online Shop & Events

If you love their coffee but don't live in the area, purchasing some coffee bags is a great way to support their business and take a taste of Eureka home with you. You can purchase all of their coffee varieties by bag and get them whole or ground to your preference. When you need a refill, just place an order online and they will ship to you!

8 oz bags: $7.75
14 oz bags: $11.95
12 oz valved bags: 11.95

Looking for a charming, affordable place to host your next event? Check out their Old Town Eureka Location! You can rent their space for your wedding shower, tea party, family get-together, and more. The cost is $25/hour with purchase of food, coffee, wine, or champagne. In addition, they are able to create guest favors and dessert platters for you at a minimal cost! You can also order delivery on door dash.

Note: They have two locations. Their main and bigger location is in Old Town while their other location is found on Henderson St. in Eureka as well.

Local Tips

Free delivery in Eureka for orders over $25.00.
There is an Old Town Location and Henderson Center location.
You can rent the party room for events!
They offer gift cards - purchase in-store or online.

Staging environment